How do Yagi Antennas work?
Perhaps, we all know that a Yagi antenna provides a unidirectional radiation lobe pattern and enhanced forward gain in comparison to a dipole. However, some might ask, what is the unique concept that makes a Yagi antenna tick? What makes it distinctively different from other types of antennas? … Fair question! We will try to examine some of the fundamentals of a Yagi-Uda antenna.
What is a Yagi antenna?
In simple terms, a Yagi antenna is an array of dipoles geometrically arranged in the plane of the primary driven dipole. All the other dipoles of the array barring only one dipole element are not electrically connected to the transmitter. The single dipole which is directly power by the transmitter is the primary dipole called the driven element. All other electrically unconnected sets of dipoles are called parasitic elements and are geometrically placed in parallel to the driven element at various distances away from the driven element. Hence the Yagi is actually a dipole array. The clever arrangement of actively driving only one dipole while letting the other parasitic dipoles be coupled to the driven element through mutual field coupling is the salient feature of a Yagi antenna. The length of these parasitic elements is almost equal to that of the main driven resonant dipole but they are not exactly equal. Some elements are made a bit longer while the others are made a bit shorter. Hence, essentially, though the parasitic elements are sized to be near resonance, they are not exactly at resonance.
Usually, a typical Yagi antenna has one parasitic element that is longer than the main driven dipole and it is placed behind the dipole. This element is called the reflector. One or more parasitic elements that are cut a bit shorter in length called the directors are placed in front of the driven dipole at various spacing distances from the dipole. Various different design configurations of the Yagi antenna may have a different number of directors. The more the number of director elements, the higher is the forward gain of the antenna, Typically, most Yagi antennas would feature several directors in front plus one reflector behind the dipole. However, some smaller Yagi configurations like the 2-element Yagi might be a reflectorless Yagi with only one director or the other way round in a directorless configuration with only the reflector.
We said before that the more the number of parasitic elements in a Yagi antenna configuration, the greater is the achievable forward gain. Though this is true, we need to bear several limiting factors in mind while designing or accessing a Yagi antenna. Firstly, it becomes impractical to increase the number of parasitic elements beyond a point. This is not merely on account of physical size constraints but also due to the fact that theoretically when we double the number of Yagi antenna elements we get an additional gain of approximately +3dB. Hence, if a 3-element Yagi produces a forward gain of say 12dBi, then a 6-element version will have a gain of 15dBi, a 12-element version will have 18dBi, a 24-element version will yield 21dBi. We notice that the law of diminishing returns starts applying beyond a point. After a point, it becomes difficult to justify the monstrous physical length of the structure which happens due to the size multiplication by a factor x2 required for each 3dB additional gain that we seek.
Another factor to keep in mind is that although a standalone dipole element would also have a finite limited usable bandwidth, the Yagi antenna configuration consisting of multiple dipoles results in a further reduction in the bandwidth in comparison to a simple dipole. The more the number of parasitic elements, the lower is the useful SWR limited bandwidth of the Yagi. A notable factor at this point is to also recognize that a compact and short boom Yagi designs will usually have a much lower bandwidth than that of a long boom design where the parasitic elements more widely spaced. This is true even if they both have the same number of elements… The fact of the matter is, everything good in life comes with a price. There is never a free lunch.
Effect of parasitic elements on the feed-point impedance of a Yagi
Normally, a typical resonant dipole in free space has a feed-point impedance of 72Ω. However, in the case of the Yagi, the close physical proximity of the parasitic elements to the driven dipole results in additional load on the dipole. The effect of parasitic loading is to reduce the impedance at the feed-point of the driven element of the dipole. The additional parasitic element loading makes the driven dipole draw more current from the transmitter which is the cause of a reduction in feed-point impedance. Therefore, the impedance of a Yagi is always less than that of the driven dipole if it were to operate as a standalone dipole in the absence of the parasitic elements. Yagi designers often try to achieve a configuration so the feed-point impedance reduces just enough to become close to 50Ω. However, this is not always the case.
Depending on the other design objectives, the parasitic element spacing and lengths are so adjusted to achieve far lower feed-point impedances. it is common to find Yagi antennas with a feed-point impedance of either 25-28Ω or 12.5Ω. These values are often preferred by Yagi designers when the Yagi is meant to be a part of a larger stacked antenna array. This makes it convenient to more easily design proper phasing harness for driving the antenna stack. Even the normal standalone Yagi would often have a feed-point impedance of around 25Ω. That is why we so often find Yagi installations using impedance matching methods like a Gamma match to match it to the nominal 50Ω characteristic impedance of common coaxial cables.
Another method often used especially for VHF/UHF compact Yagi designs, is to use a folded dipole driven element instead of a straight dipole. With a straight dipole in a compact yagi design with closely spaced elements, it is fairly common to load the driven dipole enough to achieve a 12-13Ω feed-point impedance. Now, if a folded dipole driven element were to be used instead, what would happen? The folded dipole has a 300Ω native impedance as against 72Ω for the straight dipole. This is roughly 4 times higher. Hence, a compact yagi whit a straight dipole which might have loaded the driven dipole enough to reduce the impedance from 72Ω to say 12.5Ω would load the Yagi with a folded dipole with the same ratio. In such a case, the 300Ω native impedance of the folded dipole will now get loaded just enough to produce 50Ω feed-point impedance. External impedance matching networks would not be needed anymore. All that one needs is a 1:1 Unun to connect to a 50Ω coax feeder.
Similarly, one might have seen various Yagi antennas, especially on VHF/UHF bands, that have a Quad loop as the driven element instead of a straight dipole that is normally used as a driven element. This type of Yagi is called a Quagi antenna. It derives its name from a Quad and a Yagi. Why do they use a Quagi? Is it that it provides better gain or enhanced performance? No, certainly not… All performance parameters of a Quagi are practically identical to that of a Yagi. Then, why go through all the trouble? Fair question… The answer is that a standalone Quad loop driven element has approximately 100Ω feed-point impedance. Hence, in an array with several parasitic elements, despite the additional loading of parasitic elements, the reduction in overall feed-point impedance of the Quagi antenna would reduce enough to be close to a typical 50Ω transmission line impedance. consequently, a Quagi will not need elaborate impedance matching networks unlike the Yagi in similar conditions.
How does a Yagi antenna work? How does it produce gain?
Let us see how do Yagi antennas produce forward gain. I will try to keep the narrative simple and intuitive for now and save the rest for a bit later. Before we go further, let us see how the parasitic elements of a Yagi play a role. Since they are electrically isolated from the driven element, how is it that they influence the antenna system? We know that all the parasitic elements are placed in close proximity to the driven element. Hence they are coupled to the driven element through mutual field coupling. All parasitic elements are close enough to lie within the induction field (Raliegh zone) of the driven dipole. If you have missed out on our article explaining the induction field and other zones around an antenna, then please refer to the article on Principles of Radiation to get an insight.
In the induction field region, all conductors achieve a direct coupling to the radiating element through mutual induction. These nearby conductors (parasitic elements in this case) produce a load on the radiating element (driven dipole in this case). As a consequence power is transferred to the parasitic elements from the driven dipole through mutual coupling. The degree and nature of coupling will depend on the distance and the length of the parasitic element w.r.t the radiator. This phenomenon is used to our advantage in a Yagi design, however, in day-to-day scenarios of amateur radio station antennas, this phenomenon may often play a detrimental role. For instance, nearby water pipes, overhead wires, metal in buildings like beams and columns, etc, on account of near field mutual coupling often deteriorate the overall performance of our antenna in terms of efficiency, its radiation lobe pattern, etc.
As we stated above, in the case of a Yagi antenna, the induction field mutual coupling is an asset that makes the Yagi possible. When the driven dipole is energized with the RF power from the transmitter, it produces an induction field around it. The parasitic elements which are placed within this field region absorb energy from the driven element. In turn, a current flows on the parasitic element producing its own electric and magnetic fields. These regenerated fields produced around the parasitic elements make them behave like energy radiators and consequently, these parasitic elements also radiate. This happens with all the parasitic elements of the Yagi irrespective of whether its a reflector or a director. The net result is that now, not only do we have the driven dipole as the radiator but we have multiple (induction coupled) radiators all radiating RF energy which would eventually convert into full blossomed electromagnetic (EM) waves.
The above scenario is like having multiple radiating dipoles strategically placed at a proper distance from one another. Due to the separating distance between all these radiating elements, their radiations are out of phase by a certain amount which is proportionate to the physical distance between each other. Their radiations could either constructively or destructively interfere with one another. However, what we want is that the constructive interference should be as high as possible in the forward direction of the Yagi antenna so that they enhance each other to boost the effective radiated power in the forward direction. Similarly, in the reverse direction, towards the back of the Yagi, we want to maximize destructive interference to cancel out the effective radiation.
This is where the cleverest part of the Yagi design comes into play. If we increase the length of a parasitic element beyond its resonant length, then it develops an inductive reactance resulting in a further phase delay of the reradiation from that element. That is how the reflector of the Yagi is made. It is made longer than the driven element. On the other hand, the director(s) of a Yagi is made shorter than the resonant length. This results in a capacitive reactance on the directors which results in the directors further advancing the phase of the reradiated signals. These additional phase shifts offered by the reflector and director(s) work in our favor to achieve signal strength enhancement in the forward direction while suppressing radiation in the backward direction.
Wait a minute… is that all? Nah! … Something seems to be horrendously wrong. What I described in the above paragraph would actually produce enhanced radiation in the backward direction while producing minima in the forward direction. That would be just the opposite of what we want. Oh god! where did we go wrong? … Well, relax, we didn’t get anything wrong. It’s just that, so far, I have not yet mentioned the most important fine point of a Yagi antenna design. Most narratives on the internet and elsewhere are at times a bit fuzzy about the point that we will touch upon now. Our narrative till the previous paragraph, explains the principles of a Yagi provided we ignore to speak about the lobe direction. The fact of the matter is that the Yagi indeed enhances radiation in the forward direction of the directors and not in the backward direction.
Good! So, what would explain the apparent anomaly? Surprisingly, the explanation is rather simple. We must emphasize that all parasitic elements which reradiate including the reflector and the director(s) must be short-circuited in the middle for a Yagi to function. In other words, they must be joined at the center and not be two electrically isolated pieces of 1/2 size elements on either side of the boom. This is very vital. As a consequence of the short-circuiting in the middle, the phase of the current induced in the parasitic elements gets reversed in phase by 180°. Hence, all the phase relationships we discussed so far go through a 180° phase reversal from what we described so far. Therefore, when this phenomenon is applied across the board, and applicable to all parasitic elements of the Yagi, the directions of constructive and destructive interference also get reversed by 180°. Hence, the Yagi radiation lobes do actually indeed get enhanced in the forward direction and not in the reverse direction.
If you want to dig deeper, then read the following section.
I hope you enjoyed reading the article. Perhaps some readers might have gained a better insight into the finer yet lesser-known facts about the Yagi-Uda antenna that we all admire and use quite often.